Five Guys keeps it straightforward—fresh burgers, crispy fries, and no-nonsense service. But if you know what to ask for, there’s a whole other layer to the menu. Over time, creative staff and regulars have pieced together custom orders that aren’t officially listed but are well worth trying. These off-menu picks are thoughtful twists that play to the chain’s strengths: quality ingredients and made-to-order prep. Let's check out a few secret items that show what happens when people get curious—and a little hungry—beyond the basics.
Loaded French Fries
Credit: flickr
Why settle for plain fries when you can have them loaded? At Five Guys, you can customize your fries by adding toppings like cheese, grilled onions, jalapeños, and even chopped bacon. Some adventurous diners go further by requesting a chopped-up burger patty on top.
Grilled Cheese Cheeseburger
Credit: flickr
You don't have to be torn between a grilled cheese and a burger when you have both. This off-menu delight combines the gooey goodness of a grilled cheese sandwich with the savory satisfaction of a burger. Simply order a grilled cheese and ask to have a beef patty added inside. The result is a melty, cheesy, beefy masterpiece that's sure to hit the spot. Customize it further with your favorite toppings to make it uniquely yours.
Double Grilled Cheeseburger
Credit: flickr
For those seeking the ultimate indulgence, the double grilled cheeseburger is a must-try. This creation features two grilled cheese sandwiches serving as the buns, encasing one or more beef patties along with your choice of toppings. It results in a gooey, cheesy, and hearty meal that combines the best of both worlds.
Extra Crispy Fries
Credit: Facebook
If you're a fan of crispy fries, Five Guys has you covered. Simply ask for your fries to be cooked "well done," and they'll fry them a bit longer for a crunchier bite. This simple request transforms their already delicious fries into a crispy delight.
Vegetarian BLT
Credit: Facebook
For a meat-free twist on the classic BLT, Five Guys offers a delightful alternative. Instead of bacon, this sandwich features grilled mushrooms that provide a savory, umami flavor when paired with crisp lettuce and fresh tomato. Served on a toasted bun with mayonnaise, it's a satisfying option for vegetarians or anyone seeking a lighter choice without compromising on taste.
Bacon Milkshake
Credit: Facebook
It sounds odd, but there’s something oddly satisfying about mixing smoky bacon into a thick vanilla shake, and that's what this secret menu item delivers. The Bacon Milkshake fuses crispy bacon bits into Five Guys' creamy base for a salty-sweet mashup that's rich, bold, and unforgettable.
Chicago-Style Hot Dog
Credit: Facebook
Even though Five Guys doesn't officially list it, you can pull off a Chicago-style hot dog with the right mix of toppings. Add pickles, relish, green peppers, tomatoes, mustard, and Cajun seasoning to recreate that loaded, bold flavor. It's a Midwest classic in disguise.
Burger Bowl
Credit: Facebook
If you're the kind of person who loves burgers but could skip the bun, the Burger Bowl is your move. Ask for your usual burger in a bowl, then go wild with toppings. It's easy to eat, totally customizable, and ideal if you're going low-carb or simply want all the flavor with none of the bread.
Cajun Burger
Credit: Facebook
Anyone looking to kick things up a notch without messing with the core burger should try this underrated move. Ask for Cajun seasoning on the patty before it hits the grill. It adds depth, heat, and some edge without being overpowering.
Extra Chunky Peanut Butter Shake
Credit: Reddit
There's already peanut butter on the shake menu, but this hack turns it crunchy and over-the-top. Ask for peanut butter and chocolate, then mix in the free peanuts from the counter. Add bacon or Oreos if you want chaos. It's wild, thick, and packed with texture that makes each sip extra fun.
Presidential Burger
Credit: Facebook
Barack Obama's go-to order at Five Guys made waves when he revealed it years ago—and now fans replicate it constantly. The Presidential Burger stacks cheese, lettuce, tomato, jalapeños, and mustard between classic buns. It's not overcomplicated, but the mix of heat, crunch, and tang hits all the right notes. Add pickles if you want the full effect.
In-N-Out Animal Style Burger
Credit: Facebook
This creative crossover features grilled onions, pickles, extra ketchup, and mustard grilled directly onto the patty. It's a nod to In-N-Out's famous animal style but with the franchise's signature beef and bigger build.
HB Slammer
Credit: Facebook
The HB Slammer layers two patties, two hot dogs, bacon, and cheese into one seriously intense creation. It's meaty, greasy, and unapologetically huge. You'll have to custom-build it piece by piece, but loyal fans swear by the flavor overload.
Artery Annihilator
Credit: Instagram
This item lives up to the name by packing bacon, cheese, hot dogs, and multiple patties into one sandwich. The meal is a full-scale feast in bun form. You'll need to construct it manually with the right order tweaks, but those who've tried it say it's wildly satisfying, if not slightly outrageous.
The "All the Way" Veggie Sandwich
Credit: Reddit
Ordering "all the way" usually refers to a loaded burger, but it works surprisingly well on a veggie sandwich, too. Pile on every available topping—grilled mushrooms, onions, green peppers, jalapeños, pickles, and the works. What you get is a veggie-packed beast that's saucy, messy, and full of flavor without needing a single bite of meat.
