The Weirdest Food Combos to Ever Exist
Unlikely pairings have always found their way onto the table, but some still catch people off guard. What looks strange at first often turns out to be memorable, even addictive. These are the kinds of combinations that bend the usual food rules yet keep winning over curious eaters.
Peanut Butter and Pickles
Credit: Wikimedia Commons
This sandwich pairing is often discussed in Southern kitchens and online food debates. The bold, salty bite of a dill pickle somehow fits right in with the creamy heft of peanut butter. Some prefer it on white bread, while others prefer it toasted.
French Fries and Milkshakes
Credit: Instagram
Dipping hot fries into a cold milkshake has happened at fast food counters since the 1960s. The salty-sweet contrast hits the same sensory reward zones as kettle corn or bacon-topped donuts. Fast food chains like Wendy’s are unofficial sponsors of this combo, with their Frosty being a popular go-to.
Cottage Cheese and Mustard
Credit: Reddit
On TikTok, this combination gained traction as a high-protein dip for vegetables. Cottage cheese gives it creaminess, while mustard adds bite and acidity. Together, the texture and tang become oddly addictive. Some go a step further and use it as a sandwich spread.
Hot Fudge and Soft Pretzels
Credit: Getty Images
The salt and chew of a soft pretzel turn into something different when dipped in warm fudge. It’s a mix that started showing up at fairs and concession stands and has since worked its way into sundaes and desserts. Simple, a little messy, and surprisingly satisfying.
Apples and Grilled Cheese
Credit: Reddit
Tart apples like Granny Smiths are often served on cheese boards, so layering them into a grilled cheese isn’t such a leap. The fruit’s crisp texture contrasts nicely with melty cheddar or gouda. Some even roast the apple slices first to concentrate their sweetness.
Vanilla Ice Cream and Olive Oil
Credit: Reddit
This unexpected topping went viral for a reason. A drizzle of extra virgin olive oil adds depth and fruitiness to plain vanilla. The fat content smooths the ice cream’s texture, and a pinch of sea salt makes the whole thing pop.
Cereal and Orange Juice
Credit: Reddit
Before plant-based milks were everywhere, some people with dairy intolerance turned to orange juice for their cereal. It sounds harsh, but the acidity softens oats and cornflakes while highlighting natural sweetness. Grape-Nuts and plain Cheerios are often the best match.
Avocado and Chocolate
Credit: Reddit
The Aztecs used both, though not in mousse form. Today, avocado often replaces butter or cream in chocolate desserts, which offers a dense texture without altering flavor. Vegan bakers use it for truffles, brownies, and puddings. It’s a practical pairing, especially for reducing dairy or processed ingredients.
Pickles and Kool-Aid Powder
Credit: Reddit
Popular in parts of Texas and the Deep South, Koolickles are pickles soaked in a mixture of Kool-Aid and sugar. The result is brightly colored, sweet, sour, and intensely flavored. They’ve gained viral fame and now appear at food festivals and specialty shops.
Peanuts in Cola
Credit: Reddit
A long-standing Southern tradition involves dropping salted peanuts directly into a bottle of Coke. The fizz softens the peanuts, and the sweet-salty mix becomes a drink-snack hybrid. It’s thought to have started with farmers who needed quick, one-handed refreshments during long workdays.
Balsamic Vinegar and Ice Cream
Credit: Reddit
It works, but not with just any balsamic. Aged, syrupy versions bring complexity without being sharp. When paired with vanilla ice cream, they create a flavor contrast that feels almost grown-up. Some chefs reduce balsamic to a glaze, and others drizzle it straight.
Bananas and Mayonnaise
Credit: Reddit
Sandwiches made with banana and mayo have deep roots in Southern home cooking. Often served on soft white bread, this snack dates back to the Depression, when affordable calories were more important than culinary logic. The richness of the mayo and the sweetness of ripe bananas make it filling.
Watermelon and Feta
Credit: Reddit
Now, as a common salad pairing, this used to be considered strange. Watermelon brings hydration and sugar, while feta adds a salty edge. A few mint leaves or a drizzle of lime complete the combination. The Mediterranean influence has helped this combo go from cookout curiosity to restaurant staple.
Ramen and Peanut Butter
Credit: Reddit
This budget-friendly twist on instant noodles turns the packet into a makeshift Thai-style dish. Stirring peanut butter into hot noodles gives the broth a creamy consistency. Adding soy sauce, sriracha, or garlic powder helps deepen the flavor. It’s a late-night kitchen move that stuck around.
Eggs and Ketchup
Credit: Reddit
Though it divides breakfast tables, ketchup on eggs is nothing new. The sweetness and acidity work as a substitute for tomato-based sauces. Scrambled, fried, or hard-boiled—people add ketchup across the board. Some even go for sriracha-ketchup blends for extra heat.
Pizza and Ranch Dressing
Credit: Reddit
Dipping pizza into ranch gained ground in the Midwest and spread nationally through pizza chains offering dipping cups. The creamy coolness of ranch tones down hot pepperoni or spicy sausage. While purists scoff, the pairing has become a mainstay for many delivery nights and party tables.
Jell-O and Pretzels
Credit: Reddit
Often seen at potlucks in the Midwest, Jell-O pretzel salad layers crushed pretzels, cream cheese filling, and fruit-flavored gelatin. It’s more dessert than salad, but the salty base contrasts nicely with sweet strawberry or raspberry tops. The name may confuse newcomers, but the texture combo is the real surprise.
Spaghetti and Ketchup
Credit: Reddit
It started as a pantry workaround and stuck. Ketchup mimics marinara in sweetness and tomato base without herbs and acidity. The pairing often shows up in budget cooking or children’s meals. In the Philippines, a version made with banana ketchup is standard and served in school lunches.
Chili and Cinnamon Rolls
Credit: Reddit
This combo is a cafeteria favorite in parts of the Midwest, especially Nebraska and Iowa. Chili is served with a warm cinnamon roll, not cornbread or crackers. The spice from the chili contrasts with the sugary icing in ways that sound wrong but taste comforting, especially in cold weather.
Bacon and Chocolate
Credit: Reddit
Bacon-studded chocolate bars, cupcakes, and ice cream appear in grocery aisles and dessert menus. The crisp, salty fat of the bacon offsets the richness of milk or dark chocolate. It’s an extreme example of how far sweet and savory blends have come.