The Most Popular In-N-Out Secret Menu Item Hands Down
Not many fast-food chains have built a following around off-menu orders quite like In-N-Out. The restaurant’s official menu is remarkably small, but conversations about secret menu combinations have been going strong for decades. One order, however, is at the center of fan discussions, recommendation lists, and drive-thru requests.
The Secret Menu Star That Refuses To Fade Away
Image via Reddit/curioussoaps
The Animal Style Burger has become the most popular secret menu item at In-N-Out. While customers can choose everything from Protein Style burgers wrapped in lettuce to Flying Dutchmans made with only patties and cheese, Animal Style is still the order most closely associated with the chain. And instead of reinventing the burger, it upgrades the ingredients people already love.
An Animal Style Burger starts with a standard cheeseburger and adds grilled onions, pickles, extra spread, and a mustard-grilled beef patty. The grilled onions bring sweetness, the pickles add bite, and the mustard-grilled patty creates extra flavor during cooking.
A Story That Dates Back To 1961
Image via iStockphoto/Walter Cicchetti
Part of the Animal Style Burger’s appeal comes from its history. The customization first appeared in 1961, so it’s a very old secret menu item. According to In-N-Out lore, the name came from a group of rowdy regulars who spent time around the restaurant and earned the nickname “the animals” from employees.
One member of the group saw the customized burger being prepared, wanted to try it, and quickly became a fan. Staff eventually began referring to the order as Animal Style, and the name stuck. Decades later, customers are still ordering it.
Why Fans Keep Coming Back
The secret menu offers plenty of creative options, but Animal Style consistently stands out for combining several fan-favorite modifications into a single order. Many regulars take things a step further by ordering a Double-Double Animal Style. The extra beef patty and cheese slice help balance the additional toppings.
The Upgrades Fans Swear By
Image via Wikimedia Commons/El Suizo
Animal Style may be the most famous order, but devoted customers don’t stop there. Chopped chilies rank among the most popular additions. The peppers add heat and acidity that cut through the richness of the spread and cheese.
Another favorite is the whole grilled onion. Instead of chopped onions, customers receive a full grilled onion slice that adds more texture and deeper caramelization. Some fans also request extra toasted buns to help support the additional toppings.
Bigger Than A Burger
The influence of Animal Style extends beyond burgers. Animal Style fries have become one of the chain’s most popular off-menu orders, topped with melted cheese, grilled onions, and spread. Some customers even order them well done for added crispness.
The success of Animal Style also helped establish a culture where modifications became part of the In-N-Out experience. Protein Style burgers, Neapolitan shakes, Flying Dutchmans, and larger builds like the 3×3 and 4×4 all benefit from the same spirit of customization.