Fast Food Loyalty Programs Ranked From Worst to Best
Fast food chains all want your loyalty, and the way they go after it is through their apps. Nearly every major brand has a rewards program, but they don’t all deliver the same experience. Some pile on confusing point systems, while others offer perks that are clear but underwhelming. A few stand out for turning routine orders into deals worth paying attention to. Here’s how the current lineup of loyalty programs compares, from the weakest to the strongest.
Jimmy John’s Freaky Fast Rewards
Credit: Instagram
You’ll get a free sandwich after your first order, which sounds great, until everything after that starts to feel slow. Points trickle in at a minimal rate, and rewards aren’t exactly thrilling. It works, technically, but isn’t winning any loyalty competitions.
Costa Club
Credit: X
Buy eight drinks, get one free. That’s the premise, and it’s clear. But the problem is that’s almost all it does. There’s a birthday treat and a push for reusable cups, but even with that small incentive, Costa’s rewards program feels too narrow for users who order more than just coffee.
Domino’s Rewards
Credit: Instagram
Domino’s offers free items at 40 and 60 points, but the reward options don’t always match users’ prices. A $5 purchase gets the same 10 points as a $20 one. The real standout here is the Domino’s Tracker, which remains one of the best order status tools.
Panera MyPanera
Credit: Reddit
Panera doesn’t use points, which can feel refreshing or confusing depending on the user. Rewards show up after several visits, but there’s little clarity on how they’re earned. Some users report getting free coffee, others get discounts on sandwiches—there’s no consistent pattern.
Burger King Royal Perks
Credit: Instagram
The point system is easy to follow: Crowns for every dollar spent. However, it takes a long time to earn something worthwhile. Users get a daily free upgrade and birthday bonuses, which help increase the value. But with competitors offering free food at lower thresholds, Burger King lands in the middle.
Wendy’s Rewards
Credit: X
There’s nothing complicated here: 10 points per dollar, and you can scan a QR code or a receipt if you forget your phone. Outside of the signup bonus and occasional promos, it doesn’t do much to make the experience feel special.
Pizza Hut Hut Rewards
Credit: X
Hut Rewards keeps things simple: 2 points per dollar and a free medium pizza at 200 points. It doesn’t overcomplicate the process, and that helps. There’s no tier system, expiration, or weird hoops to jump through. That said, it’s pretty bare-bones.
Subway MVP Rewards
Credit: Instagram
With over 32 million users, Subway’s revamped program focuses on tiers and improved customization. Users start earning right away, with options to level up based on annual spend. Higher tiers unlock better birthday rewards, exclusive perks, and extra points per dollar.
Jersey Mike’s Shore Points
Credit: Yelp
Here, points vary by sandwich size, which makes the system feel fairer than flat rates. No expiration dates mean you can build up to a giant sub without pressure. Birthday subs don’t require a purchase, either. While the app isn’t packed with extras, it’s consistent and leans into keeping things simple.
Dunkin’ Rewards
Credit: Instagram
Dunkin’ ditched DD Perks and added new layers like Boosted Status, Monday bonuses, and better reward variety. You can stack offers, which means users get more than just one freebie at a time. Coffee lovers benefit the most, but there are also rewards for food items and seasonal promos.
Taco Bell Rewards
Credit: X
Taco Bell offers rotating rewards, early access to new items, and exclusive deals that often beat competitors in value. Users frequently get custom offers based on past purchases. While it’s not the most intuitive interface, the surprise perks and frequent updates keep it genuinely rewarding for regulars.
Starbucks Rewards
Credit: Instagram
It’s one of the biggest for a reason. Stars are easy to earn if you pay through the app or a Starbucks card, and redemption options are flexible. Bonus Star events, games, and a Secret Menu tab make the app feel active year-round.
McDonald’s Rewards
Credit: Instagram
The program runs on a simple system: 100 points for every dollar spent, with redemptions that come fast. Daily deals and rotating promotions add extra value, and the app updates often with region-specific offers. The steady flow of rewards and discounts gives customers a reason to open the app regularly and keep using it.
Chick-fil-A One
Credit: Instagram
Chick-fil-A’s program works in tiers, with points scaling as your status goes up. Top-tier users unlock “Signature Surprises,” get to send rewards to friends, and even snag invites to behind-the-scenes events. The app even detects when you’re near a location and cues up your order.
Chipotle Rewards
Credit: Instagram
Chipotle takes the crown for how well it blends simplicity with clever features. Users earn 10 points per dollar and can redeem everything from chips to full entrées. The Extras system includes challenges and mini-games that add surprise bonuses. Real Foodprint adds sustainability stats to orders.