Oreo’s Most Hated Flavor Ever? Fans Are Still Arguing
Oreo has rolled out some wild flavors over the years, but one stood out for all the wrong reasons. Fans didn’t forget it, and they’re still debating whether it was brilliant or blasphemy. And now, we’re ranking the most eyebrow-raising, tongue-twisting weird blends released that people loved to hate. Some of them even left a strange, controversial aftertaste.
Lemon Twist
Credit: Youtube
This wasn’t offensive, but it confused traditionalists. Fans of lemon bars might have enjoyed it, but others found the citrus not prominent enough in reality, as expected from the name. It didn’t last long on shelves, though some people still search eBay for nostalgic bites.
Carrot Cake
Credit: Youtube
Carrot cake Oreos were surprisingly realistic, but that didn’t stop the drama. The spiced cookie and cream cheese-flavored filling were impressively close to the real thing, but too sweet and overpowering for some. People couldn’t get over the idea of vegetable cake in cookie form. It’s like someone baked Thanksgiving into an Oreo.
Pumpkin Spice
Credit: Reddit
Pumpkin Spice Oreos split fans into two camps: “cozy and festive” or “tastes like a Yankee Candle.” It returns every fall and gets roasted every time. The spice mix feels heavy and without a real pumpkin flavoring, and some swear it leaves a weird tang.
Kettle Corn
Credit: Youtube
Oreo thought, “Why not make a fairground in a cookie?” This flavor included puffed millet for texture, which felt oddly cereal-like and did not mesh well with the traditional chocolate cookie. The taste was buttery-sweet with a hint of salt, but reactions were lukewarm. While it wasn’t hated, people weren’t simply sure what it was trying to be.
Firework
Credit: Youtube
Fourth of July got loud with this one. Oreo added universally unappealing red and blue Pop Rocks to the cream. It was fun, chaotic, and surprisingly tasty, but the popping was too much for some. A few bites felt like chewing bubble wrap. A+ for commitment to the theme.
Cotton Candy
Credit: Reddit
Launched exclusively at Target, this one was pastel, with a dense sugar feel, and slightly overwhelming. It tasted like cotton candy and had a persistent lingering aftertaste, which weirded people out more than expected. Some called it “too sweet for a cookie,” which is saying something.
Root Beer Float
Credit: Youtube
This one had strong nostalgia energy but somehow missed the mark. People said it smelled and tasted like spiced root beer-flavored lip balm and didn’t capture that creamy float magic. Fans who wanted fizz got an estranged taste clash and plenty of strong flavor instead, and not everyone was on board. Some people liked the weirdness regardless.
Peanut Butter & Jelly
Credit: Youtube
PB&J lovers were hyped, but many called this flavor more lunchbox than dessert. The peanut butter part worked fine. But the jelly had an odd artificiality of overly sweet raspberry tang. If you ever wondered what a grape Laffy Taffy Oreo tastes like, this was your shot.
Watermelon
Credit: Youtube
The Watermelon flavor tried to capture summer in a cookie, and the result was confusing. The flavor came out in 2013 and immediately divided snack lovers. The neon filling looked radioactive, and the taste was perceived as unappetizing, closer to a Jolly Rancher or bubblegum than dessert. Even diehard fans didn’t know what to feel, besides mildly betrayed.
Candy Corn
Credit: Youtube
Candy corn’s already polarizing, so putting it inside an Oreo only stirred more drama. People either loved the novelty or said it was too artificial, and the cream tasted like frosted wax. It sold well at first, but now lives in infamy as one of Oreo’s boldest misfires.
Fruit Punch
Credit: Youtube
Fruit Punch felt like it belonged in a juice box, not a cookie aisle. It launched with bright red filling and a lot of skepticism. The taste was intense, overpowering, and could be overwhelming, with an unpleasant lingering cherry-flavored aftertaste. Reviews were savage.
Cherry Cola
Credit: Youtube
Cherry Cola Oreos included chocolate wafers and popping candy to mimic carbonation. It tasted like soda-flavored gum sandwiched between chocolate. People were fascinated but confused, and some compared it to drinking soda after brushing their teeth.
Wasabi
Credit: Youtube
Oreo went full savory for a limited-time China release. It had a mismatch between the expected taste and that of spicy, pungent wasabi. The green filling screamed, “Don’t eat me,” but some adventurous snackers swore it had a weird charm.
Hot Chicken Wing
Credit: Youtube
Another limited Chinese release, the Hot Chicken Wing blend, terrified people. It was spicy, meaty, and layered between sweet chocolate cookies. Fans called it a “prank flavor,” but curiosity made it go viral. It wasn’t supposed to taste good, but it was meant to be talked about.
Swedish Fish
Credit: Youtube
Oreo’s most notorious flavor? This is the one that still sparks online arguments and dramatic TikToks. Swedish Fish Oreos smelled like cough syrup and tasted like licorice fought with toothpaste—it was more of a medicine. To this day, no flavor has caused more confusion or passionate food rants.