Heart Experts Compare Avocado and Olive Oil—Here’s the Healthier Choice
Many people think of avocado oil and olive oil as interchangeable. They both sit in the “healthy fat” category, both come with health claims, and both cost more than the average bottle of canola oil.
But when cardiologists and dietitians start comparing their effects on the heart, we see a more detailed comparison. These oils don’t work the same way in the body.
Olive Oil Contains Unique Compounds That Protect the Heart
Image via Canva/Studio Roman
Extra virgin olive oil is the most studied oil in cardiovascular nutrition. Several trials have shown that daily use can reduce the chances of heart attacks and strokes. One reason is its polyphenol content, which is a plant compound that carries antioxidant and anti-inflammatory properties. These include oleocanthal, which acts on the same inflammation pathways as ibuprofen.
Olive oil also contains hydroxytyrosol, oleuropein, and tyrosol. These compounds support blood vessel function and help prevent oxidative stress. Research shows that polyphenols in olive oil can lower markers like C-reactive protein and protect LDL cholesterol from damage by preventing it from turning into its dangerous, oxidized form, the type strongly linked to heart disease.
Consumption of olive oil can further improve your HDL cholesterol, support healthy blood pressure, and help control blood sugar. Many of these effects appear consistently across large-scale human studies. Cardiologists often recommend it as a foundation of heart-supportive diets.
Avocado Oil Performs Better in High-Heat Cooking
On the other hand, refined avocado oil remains stable up to 520°F, which makes it suitable for high-temperature cooking. Heat-sensitive oils tend to degrade above 400°F and produce harmful compounds in the process. Meanwhile, avocado oil holds its integrity during stir-frying, roasting, and grilling. The heat-stability protects the oil’s nutrients and reduces exposure to oxidized fats.
However, the fat profile of avocado oil closely matches that of olive oil. It contains about 70% oleic acid, a monounsaturated fat linked to improved cholesterol levels. Avocado oil also provides vitamin E, beta-sitosterol, and lutein. Beta-sitosterol may reduce cholesterol absorption in the gut, while lutein supports eye and brain health.
Some research shows avocado oil can reduce triglycerides and raise HDL, although those findings come mostly from small studies. Its effects appear promising, but the research is still catching up to olive oil’s.
Flavor And Nutrient Absorption Differ Between Oils
Image via Pexels/Towfiqu barbhuiya
Avocado oil also has a neutral taste, which makes it a useful option in recipes that rely on spices, acids, or natural food flavors. It works well in mayonnaise, marinades, or baked goods where a flavored oil would interfere. Its subtle profile does not carry the bitterness or peppery bite often found in extra virgin olive oil.
Olive oil offers more complexity in both flavor and nutrient delivery. It enhances cooked vegetables, legumes, and whole grains with natural sharpness and a fruit-like finish. It also supports the absorption of fat-soluble compounds.
According to studies, using olive oil with carotenoid-rich foods, like tomatoes and greens, increases the uptake of antioxidants such as lycopene and beta-carotene. Both oils aid absorption, but olive oil brings the added benefit of active polyphenols that contribute their own protective effects.
Choosing The Better Oil Depends on the Goal
For heart health and inflammation control, olive oil offers stronger and more consistent benefits. Its polyphenol content, antioxidant capacity, and proven clinical results make it a top choice for cardiovascular protection. Dietitians and cardiologists often recommend it for everyday use, especially in raw or lightly cooked dishes.
Avocado oil excels in high-temperature applications. It works better in stir-fries, oven roasting, and searing, thanks to its high smoke point and neutral flavor. It also supports cholesterol balance and nutrient absorption, even without the same level of clinical backing.
Both oils play useful roles in a balanced diet, and keeping both of them available allows for flexibility without sacrificing nutrition or culinary results.