There was a time when dessert wasn’t a dessert unless it made a mess. These throwback ice cream trends brought joy, chaos, and a fair amount of color to childhood summers. Some of these ice cream trends had kids begging for change at the corner store, while others had parents rolling their eyes.
Sealtest Ice Cream Flavors
Credit: Reddit
Sealtest was a grocery store fixture for much of the 20th century. The brand built its reputation on reliable staples like chocolate ripple and Neapolitan. Some flavors bordered on oddly specific, but its wide distribution and steady quality made it a go-to in American homes through the ’60s and ’70s.
Choco Taco
Credit: flickr
Choco Taco debuted in 1983 and became a novelty success. This waffle cone taco shell cradled vanilla ice cream, fudgy ribbons, and a crunchy coating of peanuts and chocolate. It was sold in ice cream trucks, convenience store freezers, and gas stations across America.
Mini Melts
Credit: Reddit
Mini Melts used liquid nitrogen to create frozen dots, much like Dippin’ Dots. Unlike their bigger rival, they were sold mostly in vending machines tucked inside bowling alleys or amusement parks. Their hard-to-find status added to their mystique. They’re still around—just not always where you expect them.
Nickelodeon Green Slime Ice Pops
Credit: Youtube
If you watched Double Dare, Figure It Out, or anything on Nickelodeon in the ‘90s, you probably dreamed of getting slimed. For those not lucky enough to be drenched in neon goop on live TV, these ice pops were the next best thing. The color was unsettling yet mesmerizing, radioactive green.
Vampire’s Secret Ice Pops
Credit: Instagram
Vampire’s Secret Ice Pops looked like regular cherry popsicles until you bit into them. Then—bam!—a blood-red syrupy center oozed out like a vampire snack gone wrong. It was perfect for Halloween or any random Tuesday when you wanted to freak out your little brother.
Banana Babies
Credit: Youtube
Banana Babies, created by Diana’s Bananas, offered a frozen banana dipped in chocolate. They appealed to parents hoping for better-for-you dessert options without giving up taste. Kids didn’t seem to care about the fruit part—they just liked the chocolate coating and cool texture. The simplicity made them last.
The Fat Frog Ice Cream Bar
Credit: flickr
The Fat Frog Ice Cream Bar was shaped like a cartoon frog’s head—bright green, giant eyes made of gum, and a flavor profile that screamed artificial apple with a whisper of something vaguely citrus. It was part of a wave of character bars designed to grab kids’ attention—and sugar-craving loyalty—on sight.
Butterfinger Ice Cream Nuggets
Credit: Reddit
These frozen bite-sized bars took crunchy Butterfinger bits, rolled them in chocolate, and wrapped them all around smooth vanilla ice cream. You didn’t need a bowl, just a box and enough willpower not to eat all twelve in one sitting. They were perfect for sneak-snacking or pretending one tiny bite counted as a dessert.
Mickey's Parade Ice Cream
Credit: X
Disney didn’t play around when it came to frozen snacks. Mickey’s Parade Ice Cream bars brought the theme park magic straight to the neighborhood ice cream truck. You had bars shaped like Mickey Mouse, Goofy, and Donald Duck—complete with gumball eyes and fruit-flavored coating.
Toasted Almond Good Humor Bar
Credit: Reddit
The Toasted Almond Bar was one of Good Humor’s classiest frozen entries. It mixed vanilla ice cream with a light almond-flavored coating and a dusting of cake crumbs, which gave it a soft crunch and creamy bite.
Space-Age Freeze-Dried Ice Cream
Credit: flickr
Freeze-dried ice cream was originally developed for NASA's Apollo missions but gained popularity in museum gift shops. It looked like Styrofoam, snapped like chalk, and melted into sweet powder on your tongue. While not actually used much in space, the astronaut tie-in gave it a cool factor kids couldn’t resist.
Firecracker Pop
Credit: Youtube
First produced by Popsicle®, these red, white, and blue rocket-shaped ice pops screamed Fourth of July and left a sticky trail down the arm of every kid who’d grab one. They combined cherry, lemon, and blue raspberry in one punch.
Scribblers
Credit: ebay
These dual-stick popsicles, shaped like short crayons, came in wild rainbow flavors like grape, lime, and fruit punch. Scribblers left vibrant trails on lips and tongues. Their biggest appeal was the chance to “draw” on your mouth and share the results with friends mid-summer.
Single Scoop Cost 5 Cent
Credit: Facebook
There was a time when you could throw down a nickel and gain a full scoop of hand-packed ice cream. Five-cent scoops were standard in the 1920s and ’30s, especially at corner drugstores and diners. The flavor selection may be limited, but the joy was unlimited.
Push-Up Pops
Credit: Youtube
Push-Up Pops, introduced by Nestlé, let kids enjoy sherbet from a cardboard cylinder you pushed from the bottom. Bright flavors like orange and cherry made them a hit. The no-mess packaging and slow-melting formula made them perfect for outdoor play—and a far more iconic memory than any DIY freezer trick.
